Cryogen Spray Cooling and Higher Fluence Pulsed Dye Laser Treatment Improve Port-Wine Stain Clearance While Minimizing Epidermal Damage

/Home/Cosmetic Laser Treatments/Port Wine Stain Removal - Laser Treatment/Port Wine Stains (PWS) Treatment

Cryogen Spray Cooling and Higher Fluence Pulsed Dye Laser Treatment Improve Port-Wine Stain Clearance While Minimizing Epidermal Damage
October 1999
To cite this article: Cheng-jen Chang MD, J. Stuart Nelson MD, PhD (1999)
Cryogen Spray Cooling and Higher Fluence Pulsed Dye Laser Treatment Improve Port-Wine Stain Clearance While Minimizing Epidermal Damage
Dermatologic Surgery 25 (10), 767Ò772.
doi:10.1046/j.1524-4725.1999.99100.x

Cheng-jen Chang, MD*
*Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Chang Gung Memorial Hospital, Taipei, Taiwan, and
Beckman Laser Institute and Medical Clinic, Departments of Surgery and Dermatology,
University of California, Irvine, Irvine, California and J. Stuart Nelson, MD, PhDBeckman Laser Institute and Medical Clinic, Departments of Surgery and Dermatology,
University of California, Irvine, Irvine, California *Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Chang Gung Memorial Hospital, Taipei, Taiwan, and
Beckman Laser Institute and Medical Clinic, Departments of Surgery and Dermatology,
niversity of California, Irvine, Irvine, California
Address correspondence and reprint requests to: J. Stuart Nelson, MD, PhD, Beckman Laser Institute and Medical Clinic, 1002 Health Sciences Rd. E, Irvine, California 92612, or email: snelson@bli.uci.edu.

Abstract
Background. When a cryogen spurt is applied to the skin surface for an appropriately short period of time (on the order of tens of milliseconds), the cooling remains localized in the epidermis, while leaving the temperature of the deeper port-wine stain (PWS) blood vessels unchanged.

Objective. The objective of this study was to compare the efficacy and safety of noncooled laser treatment (NC-LT), and cryogen spray cooled laser treatment (CSC-LT) of PWS birthmarks in a large series of patients.

Methods. A retrospective review was conducted of 196 patients with head or neck PWS birthmarks treated with the pulsed dye laser (λ = 585 nm; τp= 450 μsec) over a 7-year period. Subjects' ages ranged between 2 months and 62 years; there were 109 females and 87 males, all of whom were Asian. Ninety-eight patients received NC-LT using light dosages of 5Ò7 J/cm2. Subsequently, 98 patients received CSC-LT using light dosages of 8Ò10 J/cm2. The primary efficacy measure was the quantitative assessment of the blanching response scores of NC-LT PWSs as compared, on a blinded basis, to CSC-LT PWSs.

Results. Based on chi-squared analysis, there were clinical, and statistically significant, differences in the blanching response scores favoring PWS receiving CSC-LT as compared to the NC-LT group (P< .001). Permanent scarring was noted in 3.1% (n = 3) of the patients in the NC-LT group. Permanent scarring was not observed in the CSC-LT treatment group. Transient hyperpigmentation was noted in 57% (n = 56) and 48% (n = 47) of the patients in the NC-LT and CSC-LT groups, respectively. In both groups, the transient hyperpigmentation resolved in all patients within 1 year. Two patients in the NC-LT group developed delayed permanent hypopigmentation. Permanent hypopigmentation was not observed in the CSC-LT group.

Conclusion. CSC permitted the use of higher incident light dosages leading to improved PWS clearance without producing complications such as permanent scarring or dyspigmentation.

This article is cited by:
S Hammes, S Roos, C Raulin, H-M Ockenfels, B Greve. (2007) Does dye laser treatment with higher fluences in combination with cold air cooling improve the results of port-wine stains?. Journal of the European Academy of Dermatology and Venereology 21:9, 1229Ò1233
Abstract Abstract and References Full Text Article Full Article PDF
NATHAN S. UEBELHOER, DO, MELISSA A. BOGLE, MD, BRIGITTE STEWART, CCRC, KENNETH A. ARNDT, MD, AND JEFFREY S. DOVER, MD, FRCPC, FRCP. (2007) A Split-Face Comparison Study of Pulsed 532-nm KTP Laser and 595-nm Pulsed Dye Laser in the Treatment of Facial Telangiectasias and Diffuse Telangiectatic Facial Erythema. Dermatologic Surgery 33:4, 441Ò448
Abstract Abstract and References Full Text Article Full Article PDF
Wangcun Jia, Bernard Choi, Walfre Franco, Boris Majaron, Justin Lotfi, Guillermo Aguilar, J. Stuart Nelson. (2007) Treatment of cutaneous vascular lesions using multiple-intermittent cryogen spurts and two-wavelength laser pulses: Numerical and animal studies. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 39:6, 494
CrossRef
Michael A. Childers, Walfre Franco, J. Stuart Nelson, Guillermo Aguilar. (2007) Laser surgery of port wine stains using local vacuum pressure: Changes in skin morphology and optical properties (Part I). Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 39:2, 108
CrossRef
Anne M. Chapas, Kimberly Eickhorst, Roy G. Geronemus. (2007) Efficacy of early treatment of facial port wine stains in newborns: A review of 49 cases. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 39:7, 563
CrossRef
Taro KONO, William Frederick GROFF, Hiroyuki SAKURAI, Masaki TAKEUCHI, Takashi YAMAKI, Kazutaka SOEJIMA, Motohiro NOZAKI. (2006) Evaluation of fluence and pulse-duration on purpuric threshold using an extended pulse pulsed-dye laser in the treatment of port wine stains. The Journal of Dermatology 33:7, 473Ò476
Abstract Abstract and References Full Text Article Full Article PDF
D.J. McGill and I.R. Mackay. (2006) The effect of ambient temperature on capillary vascular malformations. British Journal of Dermatology 154:5, 896Ò903
Abstract Abstract and References Full Text Article Full Article PDF
Eric F. Bernstein, MD. (2006) High-Energy 595 nm Pulsed Dye Laser Improves Refractory Port-Wine Stains. Dermatologic Surgery 32:1, 26Ò33
Abstract Abstract and References Full Text Article Full Article PDF
Sang-Hyuk Woo, MD, Hyo-Hyun Ahn, MD, Soo-Nam Kim, MD, and Young-Chul Kye, MD. (2006) Treatment of Vascular Skin Lesions with the Variable Pulse 595 nm Pulsed Dye Laser. Dermatologic Surgery 32:1, 41Ò48
Abstract Abstract and References Full Text Article Full Article PDF
Wangcun Jia, Guillermo Aguilar, Wim Verkruysse, Walfre Franco, J. Stuart Nelson. (2006) Improvement of port wine stain laser therapy by skin preheating prior to cryogen spray cooling: A numerical simulation. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 38:2, 155
CrossRef
Taro Kono, Hiroyuki Sakurai, William Frederick Groff, Henry H. Chan, Masaki Takeuchi, Takashi Yamaki, Kazutaka Soejima, Motohiro Nozaki. (2006) Comparison study of a traditional pulsed dye laser versus a long-pulsed dye laser in the treatment of early childhood hemangiomas. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 38:2, 112
CrossRef
David J. Goldberg, Ellen S. Marmur, Snehal Amin, Mussarat Hussain. (2006) Comparative treatment of small diameter (&#8804;400 µm) vascular lesions using extended pulse dye lasers. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 38:2, 106
CrossRef
Arielle N.B. Kauvar, Nathan Rosen, Tatiana Khrom. (2006) A newly modified 595-nm pulsed dye laser with compression handpiece for the treatment of photodamaged skin. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 38:9, 808
CrossRef
Tianhong Dai, Mohammad A. Yaseen, Parmeswaran Diagaradjane, David W. Chang, Bahman Anvari. (2006) Comparative study of cryogen spray cooling with R-134a and R-404a: implications for laser treatment of dark human skin. Journal of Biomedical Optics 11:4, 041116
CrossRef
Julio C Ramirez-San-Juan, Bernard Choi, Walfre Franco, J Stuart Nelson, Guillermo Aguilar. (2006) Effect of ambient humidity on light transmittance through skin phantoms during cryogen spray cooling. Physics in Medicine and Biology 51:1, 113
CrossRef
Taro Kono, William Frederick Groff, Hiroyuki Sakurai. (2006) Treatment of Port Wine Stains With the Pulse Dye Laser. Annals of Plastic Surgery 56:4, 460
CrossRef
Vivek Sivarajan, William M. Maclaren, Iain R. Mackay. (2006) The Effect of Varying Pulse Duration, Wavelength, Spot Size, and Fluence on the Response of Previously Treated Capillary Vascular Malformations to Pulsed-Dye Laser Treatment. Annals of Plastic Surgery 57:1, 25
CrossRef
Julio C. Ramirez-San-Juan, Guillermo Aguilar, Alia T. Tuqan, Kristen M. Kelly, J. Stuart Nelson. (2005) Skin model surface temperatures during single and multiple cryogen spurts used in laser dermatologic surgery. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 36:2, 141
CrossRef
Stefan Hammes, Christian Raulin. (2005) Evaluation of different temperatures in cold air cooling with pulsed-dye laser treatment of facial telangiectasia. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 36:2, 136
CrossRef
Guillermo Aguilar, Walfre Franco, Jie Liu, Lars O. Svaasand, J. Stuart Nelson. (2005) Effects of hypobaric pressure on human skin: Implications for cryogen spray cooling (Part II). Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 36:2, 130
CrossRef
Brian M. Pikkula, David W. Chang, Tianhong Dai, Bahman Anvari. (2005) Epidermal and vascular damage analysis of in vivo human skin in response to 595 nm pulsed laser irradiation. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 37:1, 19
CrossRef
Vivek Sivarajan, Iain R. Mackay. (2005) Noninvasive In Vivo Assessment of Vessel Characteristics in Capillary Vascular Malformations Exposed to Five Pulsed Dye Laser Treatments. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery 115:5, 1245
CrossRef
Tianhong Dai, Parmeswaran Diagaradjane, Mohammad A. Yaseen, Brian M. Pikkula, Sharon Thomsen, Bahman Anvari. (2005) Laser-induced thermal injury to dermal blood vessels: Analysis of wavelength (585 nm vs. 595 nm), cryogen spray cooling, and wound healing effects. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 37:3, 210
CrossRef
Eric F. Bernstein, Douglas B. Brown. (2005) Efficacy of the 1.5 millisecond pulse-duration, 585 nm, pulsed-dye laser for treating port-wine stains. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 36:5, 341
CrossRef
Taro Kono, Ali Rza Er??????en, Hiroaki Nakazawa, Motohiro Nozaki. (2005) Treatment of Hypertrophic Scars Using a Long-Pulsed Dye Laser With Cryogen-Spray Cooling. Annals of Plastic Surgery 54:5, 487
CrossRef
Brian M. Pikkula, David W. Chang, J. Stuart Nelson, Bahman Anvari. (2005) Comparison of 585 and 595 nm laser-induced vascular response of normal in vivo human skin. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 36:2, 117
CrossRef
S.W. Lanigan and S.M. Taibjee. (2004) Recent advances in laser treatment of port-wine stains. British Journal of Dermatology 151:3, 527Ò533
Abstract Abstract and References Full Text Article Full Article PDF
Wai Sun Ho, FRCS, Shun Yuen Ying, FRCS, Pik Chu Chan, RN, and Henry H. Chan, MD, FRCP. (2004) Treatment of Port Wine Stains with Intense Pulsed Light: A Prospective Study. Dermatologic Surgery 30:6, 887Ò891
Abstract Abstract and References Full Text Article Full Article PDF
Guillermo Aguilar, Henry Vu, J Stuart Nelson. (2004) Influence of angle between the nozzle and skin surface on the heat flux and overall heat extraction during cryogen spray cooling. Physics in Medicine and Biology 49:10, N147
CrossRef
Baerbel Greve, Christian Raulin. (2004) Prospective study of port wine stain treatment with dye laser: Comparison of two wavelengths (585 nm vs. 595 nm) and two pulse durations (0.5 milliseconds vs. 20 milliseconds). Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 34:2, 168
CrossRef
Wangcun Jia, Guillermo Aguilar, Guo-Xiang Wang, J Stuart Nelson. (2004) Heat-transfer dynamics during cryogen spray cooling of substrate at different initial temperatures. Physics in Medicine and Biology 49:23, 5295
CrossRef
Henry Vu, Guillermo Aguilar, J. Stuart Nelson. (2004) Passive mass deposition control of cryogen sprays through the use of wire meshes. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 34:4, 329
CrossRef
Chun-Hung Chiu, MPhil, Henry Hin-Lee Chan, FRCP, Wai-Sun Ho, FRCS, Chi-Keung Yeung, MRCP, and J. Stuart Nelson, MD, PhD. (2003) Prospective Study of Pulsed Dye Laser in Conjunction With Cryogen Spray Cooling for Treatment of Port Wine Stains in Chinese Patients. Dermatologic Surgery 29:9, 909Ò915
Abstract Abstract and References Full Text Article Full Article PDF
Tina S. Alster, MD;Elizabeth L. Tanzi, MD. (2003) Laser Surgery in Dark Skin. SKINmed 2:2, 80Ò85
Summary Abstract and References Full Text Article Full Article PDF
L.O. Svaasand, L.L. Randeberg, G. Aguilar, B. Majaron, S. Kimel, E.J. Lavernia, J.S. Nelson. (2003) Cooling efficiency of cryogen spray during laser therapy of skin. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 32:2, 137
CrossRef
Emil Karapetian, Guillermo Aguilar, Sol Kimel, Enrique J Lavernia, J Stuart Nelson. (2003) Effects of mass flow rate and droplet velocity on surface heat flux during cryogen spray cooling. Physics in Medicine and Biology 48:1, N1
CrossRef
Tianhong Dai, Brian M. Pikkula, James W. Tunnell, David W. Chang, Bahman Anvari. (2003) Thermal response of human skin epidermis to 595-nm laser irradiation at high incident dosages and long pulse durations in conjunction with cryogen spray cooling: An ex-vivo study. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 33:1, 16
CrossRef
Ahmad Edris, Bernard Choi, Guillermo Aguilar, J. Stuart Nelson. (2003) Measurements of laser light attenuation following cryogen spray cooling spurt termination. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 32:2, 143
CrossRef
Taro Kono, Ali R??za Er??????en, Hiroaki Nakazawa, Takashi Honda, Nobukazu Hayashi, Motohiro Nozaki. (2003) The Flashlamp-Pumped Pulsed Dye Laser (585 nm) Treatment of Hypertrophic Scars in Asians. Annals of Plastic Surgery 51:4, 366
CrossRef
Guillermo Aguilar, Guo-Xiang Wang, J. Stuart Nelson. (2003) Dynamic behavior of cryogen spray cooling: Effects of spurt duration and spray distance. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 32:2, 152
CrossRef
Richard Azizkhan. (2003) Current Opinion in Pediatrics 15:3, 243
CrossRef
James W. Tunnell, Lihong V. Wang, Bahman Anvari. (2003) Optimum Pulse Duration and Radiant Exposure for Vascular Laser Therapy of Dark port-wine Skin: A Theoretical Study. Applied Optics 42:7, 1367
CrossRef
Henry H.L. Chan, Lai-kun Lam, David S.Y. Wong, W.I. Wei. (2003) Role of skin cooling in improving patient tolerability of Q-switched Alexandrite (QS Alex) laser in nevus of Ota treatment. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 32:2, 148
CrossRef
Henry H. Chan, FRCP, Murad Alam, MD, Taro Kono, MD, and Jeffery S. Dover, MD, FRCPC. (2002) Clinical Application of Lasers in Asians. Dermatologic Surgery 28:7, 556Ò563
Abstract Abstract and References Full Text Article Full Article PDF
Guillermo Aguilar, Sergio H. DÃaz, Enrique J. Lavernia, J. Stuart Nelson. (2002) Cryogen spray cooling efficiency: Improvement of port wine stain laser therapy through multiple-intermittent cryogen spurts and laser pulses. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 31:1, 27
CrossRef
Arielle N.B. Kauvar, Kathryn E. Frew, Paul M. Friedman, Roy G. Geronemus. (2002) Cooling gel improves pulsed KTP laser treatment of facial telangiectasia. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 30:2, 149
CrossRef
Cheng-Jen Chang, Kristen M. Kelly, Martin J.C. van Gemert, J. Stuart Nelson. (2002) Comparing the effectiveness of 585-nm vs. 595-nm wavelength pulsed dye laser treatment of port wine stains in conjunction with cryogen spray cooling. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 31:5, 352
CrossRef
Boris Majaron, Lars O Svaasand, Guillermo Aguilar, J Stuart Nelson. (2002) Intermittent cryogen spray cooling for optimal heat extraction during dermatologic laser treatment. Physics in Medicine and Biology 47:18, 3275
CrossRef
Wai Sun Ho, Henry H Chan, Shun Yuen Ying, Pik Chu Chan. (2002) Laser treatment of congenital facial port-wine stains: Long-term efficacy and complication in Chinese patients. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 30:1, 44
CrossRef
Baerbel Greve, MD, Stefan Hammes, MD, and Christian Raulin, MD. (2001) The Effect of Cold Air Cooling on 585 nm Pulsed Dye Laser Treatment of Port-Wine Stains. Dermatologic Surgery 27:7, 633Ò636
Abstract Abstract and References Full Text Article Full Article PDF
Henry H. Chan, Lai-kun Lam, David S.Y. Wong, Ronald S.C. Leung, Shun-yuen Ying, Cham-fai Lai, Wai-sun Ho, John K.H. Chua. (2001) Nevus of Ota: A new classification based on the response to laser treatment. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 28:3, 267
CrossRef
Cheng-Jen Chang, Kristen M. Kelly, J. Stuart Nelson. (2001) Cryogen Spray Cooling and Pulsed Dye Laser Treatment of Cutaneous Hemangiomas. Annals of Plastic Surgery 46:6, 577
CrossRef
Boris Majaron, Sol Kimel, Wim Verkruysse, Guillermo Aguilar, Karl Pope, Lars O. Svaasand, Enrique J. Lavernia, J. Stuart Nelson. (2001) Cryogen spray cooling in laser dermatology: Effects of ambient humidity and frost formation. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 28:5, 469
CrossRef
Guillermo Aguilar, Boris Majaron, Karl Pope, Lars O. Svaasand, Enrique J. Lavernia, J. Stuart Nelson. (2001) Influence of nozzle-to-skin distance in cryogen spray cooling for dermatologic laser surgery. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 28:2, 113
CrossRef
Boris Majaron, Wim Verkruysse, Kristen M. Kelly, J. Stuart Nelson. (2001) Er:YAG laser skin resurfacing using repetitive long-pulse exposure and cryogen spray cooling: II. Theoretical analysis. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 28:2, 131
CrossRef
Henry H. Chan, FRCP (Glas), Edmond Chan, FRCS, Taro Kono, MD, Shun-Yuen Ying, FRCS, and Wai-Sun Ho, FRCS. (2000) The Use of Variable Pulse Width Frequency Doubled Nd:YAG 532 nm Laser in the Treatment of Port-Wine Stain in Chinese Patients. Dermatologic Surgery 26:7, 657Ò661
Abstract Abstract and References Full Text Article Full Article PDF
James W. Tunnell, J. Stuart Nelson, Jorge H. Torres, Bahman Anvari. (2000) Epidermal protection with cryogen spray cooling during high fluence pulsed dye laser irradiation: An ex vivo study. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 27:4, 373
CrossRef
J. Stuart Nelson, Sol Kimel. (2000) Safety of cryogen spray cooling during pulsed laser treatment of selected dermatoses. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine 26:1, 2
CrossRef

Blackwell Synergy? is a Blackwell Publishing, Inc. registered trademark

You can view the abstract online. A subscription is required to view the full text or it can be purchased online.